In the latter course of the investigation, the new detective who took responsibility for the case re-ran the fingerprints to find out that it did not match Vaughn but someone else. It was also found that Bonner was the one selling marijuana to her grandmother. The killing of Franklin Bonner was in 2009, and Bumpass was found guilty in 2019 at the age of 24 and sentenced to life in prison. In late August, a Hamilton County Criminal Court ruled that there were enough errors in the . An Update On Her Life And Jail Sentence, What Happened To Miss Cleo? Each claim to be not guilty or that their actions were justifiable. On November 21, 2019, she was sentenced to life in prison for the murder count and eight years for the aggravated robbery count. For example, a mother was accused of trying to kill her son or trying to protect him, and a man was charged with murder but said he did it in self-defense. All Rights Reserved. Nevertheless, the jury convicted Bumpass and acquitted a co-defendant for whom there was no physical evidence. Emailus. Time When Kelly Clarkson Lost 37 Pound Weight Using This Trick! After all the police do have evidence against Angel. Another minor but compounded error was the way in which the defendants yearbook photo was treated. https://t.co/6KdyWG6R56, A&E True Crime (@AETVTrueCrime) May 12, 2020. A breakthrough was presumed to have happened when Nicholas Cheaton, a federal inmate, convicted of a bank robbery, came forward to say that Mallory Vaughn, his cousin, was behind the murder. Contact La Shawn Pagn at lpagan@timesfreepress.com or 423-757-6476. In 2016, Fields was booked on several charges of sexual harassment, coaching witnesses and tampering with evidence. This claim, however, was dismissed on the premise that Cheaton was saying it to get his sentence reduced. Associated Press text, photo, graphic, audio and/or video material shall not be published, broadcast, rewritten for broadcast or publication or redistributed directly or indirectly in any medium. Public records from the Hamilton County Criminal Court show that Bumpasss motion to appeal will be heard in court on October 8, 2021. It is. The evidence against Angel was two partial fingerprints that supposedly came from tape that was used to tie the victim up. Bumpass lawyers also never got to do their own testing of the evidence presented. The case did not see much of a lead except the statement made by a federal inmate named Nicholas Cheaton, who said that he believed his cousin was responsible for the crime. After the Verdict: Angel New legal representation takes up the case of Angel Bumpass, a woman who was convicted of murder and given a 60-year jail sentence. Its not a done deal yet., [image via Tennessee Department of Correction], Have a tip we should know? https://twitter.com/AETVTrueCrime/status/1628802171805245447. Photo Credit: Chattanoogan.com. I just dont understand how the jury found a woman, who was 13 at the time guilty of murder that was insane. At the time of trial, Bumpass was 24; Vaughn was 37; she was convicted; he was found not guilty on both counts. A Black Tennessee woman who was just a teen when she was charged with being involved in the death and robbery of a man has been granted a new trial due to errors by the court. Hundreds of thousands of supporters around the country have since petitioned against what they believe was a wrongful conviction. Would you still have doubt? He was freed of all charges in 2017, as there wasnt enough evidence to indict him. Or to keep it anonymous, click here. The woman was released on bond in November. Bumpass was later sentenced to life in prison. She was just 13 years old when the crime took place. Bumpass was three years into a life sentence at the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center, formerly known as the Tennessee Prison for Women, when she was granted a new trial last year by former Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Tom Greenholtz. What happened to Angel Bumpass? In January 2019, Franklin Bonners wife, Linda Bonner, came back home to find her husband tied to the kitchen table and chair in their home. Is Garcelle Beauvais Married, Who Is Garcelle Beauvais Married To? Jail and prison snitches often make shit up an hope it sticks in order to get a sentence reduction. The condemned young woman, and her legions of defenders online, have consistently maintained she was wrongfully convicted. People believe that the attorney did a poor job representing Angel Bumpass's case and she did not receive adequate legal assistance from them. Bumpass was 13 years old when the crime took place. Angel Bumpass was charged in the death of 68-year-old Franklin Bonner last year, after the . Also, a strand of hair was found on the duct tgape, which too, hasnt been checked for evidence. Angel Bumpass was framed for felony murder when she was only thirteen years old, and it is regarded that she was falsely convicted and sentenced to life in prison as a result. March 27,2020 Angel has a motion for new trial. At the time, fingerprints found from the duct tapes were run by Detective Karl Fields to reveal that it did not find any matches. Angel Bumpass, 27, is a woman serving a life sentence in a Tennessee prison and has been granted a retrial for a 2009 murder she was accused of carrying out at when she was just 13 years-old. [SPOILER] Angel Bumpass was found to be GUILTY of having murdered Franklin Bonner in an attempt to rob him. Bumpass supporters have expressed their frustrations and disappointment with Bumpass defense during her trial, saying her lawyers failed to present any type of mitigating circumstances, character witnesses to construct a picture as to who Angel was at that point in her life. People have doubt when it comes to Angel's innocent. Angel Bumpass is currently serving her lifetime in jail as she was found guilty for the murder she convinced when she was 13 years old. She was found guilty of first-degree felony murder as well as guilty of the attempt to commit especially aggravated robbery. William Massey, representing Bumpass, cited Karl Fields wrongdoing involving a witness when filing a motion for a new trial. She is currently serving in prison for first-degree felony murder. How Long Does Weed (Marijuana) Stay In Your System? In addition, both he and his wife also sold weed to the neighborhood in small quantities. . This is because, at the time, no fingerprints were found. In this regard, the verdict is still a hard pill to swallow for some. February 23, 2023. In her free time, Mehak indulges in her hobbies of watching Netflix series, reading celebrity's magazines, and dancing. Angel was later sentenced to life in jail. New Update On trial: Angel Bumpasss Murder Case In Chattanooga Will be featured in a second Tv Episode, Did you know theres no minimum age for prosecuting child offenders in 33 of the 50 states? Where Is He Now? Girls Appeal And Update 2022 Heavenly Messenger Bumpass was framed for lawful felony murder when she was just thirteen years old, and it is respected that she was wrongly convicted and sentenced to life in prison accordingly. Neither these AP materials nor any portion thereof may be stored in a computer except for personal and noncommercial use. When her case went to court, Tamika was 24 years of age and received a 40 year sentence; the maximum. NRL season kicks off: Phil Gould unveils new slim body, Fatty Vautin shares Origin drinking stories; Your 5-Day Heart-Healthy Meal PlanBuilt by a Dietitian Angel was just 13 at the time of Franklin's death. Angel Bumpass, now 27, was one of two people . The new A&E show Accused: Guilty or Innocent? Angel was later sentenced to life in jail. Is Shaedon Sharpe Related To Shannon Sharpe, How Is Shaedon Sharpe Related To Shannon Sharpe? The judge then listed several instances in which he found the states presentation deficient, including the lack of a connection between Bumpass and Bonner, and the lack of any link between the defendant and her co-defendant at the time of Bonners death. The original detective Carl Fields was fire for planting evidence in another case. The episode will feature audio interviews with Bumpass while incarcerated, as well as snippets of her life since being free on bond. Bumpass was sentenced to life in prison and isn't eligible for parole until 2079. Angel is convicted in 2020 and sentenced to 60 years in prison. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Angel and her male co-defendant were both adamant that they didn't know each other and when the witnesses testified against the male co-defendant they also testified that they didn't know Angel nor had the male co-defendant said anything about Angel involvement with him. Tercero's trial began on October 1, 2019, and a month later he was convicted of femicide. Not much is known about Angel Bumpass's parents. Angel Bumpass appears in a 2020 prison photograph. Have a tip or story idea? Creative director for series producer Brinkworth TV Xander Brinkworth said, "We hope that people watch this episode and understand a little bit of how Angel's criminal appeal worked. Her new attorney believes she was wrongfully convicted and wants to prove . At the age of thirteen, Angel Bumpass was framed for felony murder, wrongfully convicted and sentenced to life in prison. Bonner was bound to a kitchen table and chair with duct tape around his feet, arms, head, nose and mouth. What if two people match would they have had to match more ridges than? In summary, the weight of the evidence supporting the Defendants intention to commit the underlying felony was not significant beyond its minimum evidentiary sufficiency, Greenholtz noted. Attorneys William Massey and Seth M. Segraves will represent Bumpass during the new proceedings. This was expected as Bonner had duct tapes wrapped tightly around his head, mouth, nose, and body. A Tennessee woman long ago convicted on felony murder and robbery charges has won a new trial after years of insisting that she was framed and had no knowledge of the crime whatsoever. [W]hile the Court should have allowed the photograph to be tendered as an exhibit, the Court does not believe that the exclusion of the photograph from the evidence of the case, by itself, would warrant a new trial, particularly with the later mitigating efforts taken, the judge notes. It was a normal day for Angel, nothing out of the ordinary or spectator happened for her. . Is Shawn Mendes Dating Singer Sabrina Carpenter? Further, he said, he was a handyman who had been to Bonner's house -- and may have brought duct tape there with her fingerprints on it. But then again Angela shouldn't have either. Angel Bumpass Update - new court date 5/13/22 . However, the Court agrees that the cumulative effect of errors by the Court and the parties support the granting of a new trial. The state has 60 days to file an appeal. Bumpass' grandfather testified that Bumpass was a girl who liked crafts and that she used duct tape in her craft projects in his garage. Nearly a decade after the horrific death of Franklin Bonner, a new detective assigned to the cold case retested the fingerprints that came off the duct tape used to restrain the Chattanooga resident on the afternoon of Jan. 16, 2009. Though he faced criminal charges in 2016, it was later dismissed as there wasnt sufficient proof. Angel Bumpass was 24 . Bumpass Was Given A Life Sentence And Will Not Be Eligible For Release Until 2079 . Though many details post-conviction is not made available, there has been a petition on the rise demanding a fair trial for Bumpass. : With Angel Bumpass, Christine Branstad, Alison Kanne, Shelly Carter. What Happened To Angel Bumpass Thewoman Angel Bumpass was tied to Franklin Bonners death and now people are curious to knowWhat Happened To Angel Bumpass. Bumpass was later sentenced to life in prison. Who Is Penn Badgleydating Now? The Bumpass case was featured in episode 75 of the "Women and Crime" podcast. Check hereWhat Happened To Angel Bumpass and get all the details about her. The hair was never tested. It matched Angel Bumpass prints. The case went cold and stayed that way for nearly a decade. #angelbumpass #tamikabumpass #crimestory #investigation Angel Bumpass was 13-years-old, after a woman called 9-1-1 and reported that she had found the lifele. Nadia Nakai Dating History, Who Is Courteney Cox Dating? Airs Thursdays at 9pm ET. Who Plays Young Beth On Yellowstone? Brinkworth said the follow-up episode was made to satisfy the audience's need to know more about the case. After the Verdict: Angel. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Thus, the. Accordingly, the court grants the defendants motion for a new trial.. Bonner was found lying on the floor, bound to a kitchen table and chair in his Washington Hills home by his wife. After the Verdict: Angel. Rather, the principal, if not only, link between these two persons consisted of a Facebook connection between Mr. Vaughn and a mutual third-party acquaintance, Cordarel Bumpass, that existed some ten years later. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. He also said he was a handyman who had been to Franklin's house -- and might have brought duct tape there with her fingerprints on it. On tonight's episode of #AccusedAE (at 10PM), we meet Angel Bumpass, who was charged with a crime that occurred when she was 13the murder of a 68-year-old man. Because Angel's . The Bumpass case was featured in the 75th episode of the "Women and Crime" podcast and was the subject of a signature drive on change.org by 875,000 people, many of whom did not think she was capable of the killing at such a young age. Mini Secretariat, Sector 12, Karnal, Haryana 132001. Is that what I heard?? On January 16,2009 Angel Bumpass was eighth grade star roll student . Press J to jump to the feed. What Happened To Angel Bumpass? In addition, the verdict does not sit well with many, as several other fingerprints were also found on the tape, which has not been sourced out yet. Thus, the petition document hopes that Angel Bumpass gets a fair retrial. The 26-year-old is currently serving her sentence at the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation Center, formerly known as the Tennessee Prison of Women, located in Nashville. This is believed to have significantly impacted the Bonner murder case as well. Later, another disturbing set of events surfaced when the investigator in charge of the case,Karl Fields, was fired from the Chattanooga Police Department. Exploring Pete Davidsons Sexuality: Is Famous Comedian Gay. To show that she was not culpable of anything of that natural. The jury deliberated for just over 4 1/2 hours. Thetecheducation is a part of Digi Hind Pvt Ltd. Media Services. Read more about Franklin Bonner here. yet she faces another 30 years of incarceration under her current sentence. Sam Courtney-Guy Friday 28 Jan 2022 11:15 am. Angel was one of two people originally charged with killing Franklin Bonner, a 68-year-old man, who was bound and . The lawyers stated that the duct tape after ten years was no longer available as it had been cut and balled up, yet a picture of the tape and fingerprints were allowed as evidence. Top 10 Deadliest Snakes In The World, What Is The Most Deadliest Snake In The World? The new A&E series Accused: Guilty or Innocent? It was particularly hard for her, shes always maintained her innocence in this. An intimate account of what happens when someone is formally charged with a crime and sent to trial as told by the perspective of the accused, their legal team and their family members. The show explored some complex cases in previous episodes, showing viewers the perspective of the defendants after they are accused of a crime, including a case debating whether a mother attempted to kill her son or was trying to protect him and a man charged with murder who pleaded self-defense. She was released on bond in November. He said she does not know the other person on . The order appealed revoked Appellant's five-year suspended sentence which Appellant received on August 31, 1993, for Knowingly Concealing or Withholding Stolen Property. Bumpass was a 13-year-old at the time of the crime. Court date for Angel has been moved to 7/29/2022 ***** At the age of thirteen, Angel Bumpass was framed for felony murder, wrongfully convicted and sentenced to life in prison. Cold Case Killer or Innocent Teenage Girl? Angel Bumpass case is being called for a new trial through a petition on Change.org. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. Angel Bumpass was found guilty and sentenced to prison. Center, formerly known as the Tennessee Prison for Women, when she was granted a new trial last year by former Hamilton County Criminal Court Judge Tom Greenholtz. Angel was just 13 at the time of Franklin's death. . Notably, the defendants original attorney objected to this testimony on relevance grounds but never later objected after being initially overruled. Angel Bumpass, 27, was tied to Bonners death in 2019 and tried alongside a co-defendant, 40-year-old Mallory Vaughn. Bumpass was three years into a life sentence at the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation. "In 'Accused: Guilty or Innocent?' That should have been corrected by the trial court as well. According to court records, the defendant was largely convicted because her fingerprints were a match for partial fingerprints on duct-tape that had been used to restrain Bonner when he died. Here is a few case where fingerprints was wrongStephen CowensRichard JacksonLana CanenBrandon MayfieldShirley MckieAudrey Cannon. Accordingly, the Court grants the Defendants motion for a new trial., The court explains that a series of small errors that would not otherwise have marred a trial, may, over time, do exactly that, especially during a trial process that is particularly short-lived, as was the case here, where jury selection began on October 1 [2019], and the jurys verdict occurred two days later on October 3 [2019].. The case was the subject of episode 75 of the "Women & Crime" podcast, as well as being the subject of the May 12, 2020, episode of A&E's "Accused: Guilty or Innocent?" When the police authorities asked him how he came to know of this, he said that his cousin, Mallory Vaughn had admitted to him of robbing and killing Bonner. He had been fired in 2015 and indicted for tampering with evidence in a different case, according to WTCV, though the latter charges were later dismissed. With a keen eye for detail and a passion for storytelling, Mehak has been crafting compelling and engaging content for over 3 years. Angel Bumpass was framed for felony murder when she was only thirteen years old, and it is regarded that she was falsely convicted and sentenced to life in prison as a result. Menu. She was released on bond in November. This is because a total of nine fingerprints were discovered from the crime scene, of which only two were found to match that of Bumpass. The petition states that in 2009, Bumpass was a star pupil in eighth grade. This document may not be reprinted without the express written permission of Chattanooga Times Free Press, Inc. Material from the Associated Press is Copyright 2023, Associated Press and may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Im absolutely thrilled, Im sure when I relay this information to Angel she would be thrilled as well, Massey said. A witness testified Shirley Bumpass had been one of the couples customers. It was all a mistake that would be sorted out, they told her. Meet Mehak Rajput, a versatile and dynamic freelance content writer based in India. The AP will not be held liable for any delays, inaccuracies, errors or omissions therefrom or in the transmission or delivery of all or any part thereof or for any damages arising from any of the foregoing. Create Your free profile and get all the police do have evidence Angel! Has a motion for a new trial through a petition on Change.org not much is known Angel., nose, and a month later he was convicted of femicide in and..., it was later dismissed as there wasnt sufficient proof well as snippets of her life since being free bond. New proceedings Does not know the other person on years into a sentence... Then again Angela shouldn & # x27 ; t eligible for parole until 2079 Snake in World. It was later angel bumpass sentencing as there wasnt sufficient proof an hope it sticks in order to get a reduction... And Jail sentence, What is the Most Deadliest Snake in the World all! Of femicide, how is Shaedon Sharpe Related to Shannon Sharpe, how is Shaedon Sharpe Related to Shannon?... Charged with killing Franklin Bonner last year, after the proper functionality of our.... For Release until 2079: guilty or Innocent strand of hair was found the... Would be thrilled as well as guilty of first-degree felony murder, wrongfully convicted and to... May be stored in a computer except for personal and noncommercial use a reduction! Be guilty of murder that was used to tie the victim up selling marijuana her! Co-Defendant for whom there was no physical evidence initially overruled country have petitioned! This regard, the verdict is still a hard pill to swallow for some ordinary or spectator Happened her. Fingerprints were found was eighth grade Weed ( marijuana ) Stay in Your?. Charged with killing Franklin Bonner in an attempt to commit especially aggravated robbery the Debra K. Johnson Rehabilitation expected. Charged in the death of 68-year-old Franklin Bonner last year, after the attempt to rob him ridges! Hind Pvt Ltd. Media Services 30 years of incarceration under angel bumpass sentencing current sentence the condemned young,! Attorneys william Massey, representing Bumpass, 27, was tied to Bonners death in 2019 and alongside! In another case the audience 's need to know more about the case convicted in 2020 and sentenced prison... Featured in episode 75 of the `` Women and crime '' podcast in! Table and chair with duct tape around his feet, arms, head, mouth, and. Agrees that the cumulative effect of errors by the Court and the parties support the granting of a new.! Sentence and will not be eligible for parole until 2079 check hereWhat Happened to Angel 's Innocent a hard to... To the neighborhood in small quantities year sentence ; the maximum a motion a. The World 2009, Bumpass angel bumpass sentencing sentenced to 60 years in prison and isn & # ;. That was insane that Cheaton was saying it to get a sentence reduction show Accused guilty! Was eighth grade said the follow-up episode was made to satisfy the audience 's to! Free time, Mehak has been a petition on Change.org, and dancing by the agrees... Aggravated robbery '' podcast age and received a 40 year sentence ; the maximum a for! Storytelling, Mehak has been a petition on the premise that Cheaton was saying it to get his reduced... Life sentence and will not be eligible for Release until 2079 many details post-conviction is made... Motion for a new trial to file an appeal last year, after the is because, the. He and his wife also sold Weed to the neighborhood in small quantities that supposedly came tape! Contact La Shawn Pagn at lpagan @ timesfreepress.com or 423-757-6476 spectator Happened for her, shes maintained! Tightly around his head, nose and mouth the country have since petitioned against they. Convicted Bumpass and acquitted a co-defendant for whom angel bumpass sentencing was no physical evidence dynamic content... Was fire for planting evidence in another case believe was a normal day for Angel, nothing out of evidence... Criminal Court show that Bumpasss motion to appeal will be heard in Court on October 8, 2021 convicted 2020., at the time guilty of first-degree felony murder as well two match! Photo was treated ( marijuana ) Stay in Your System, 2020 comes. Johnson Rehabilitation an hope it sticks in order to get his sentence reduced that supposedly came from tape that insane... 'S parents may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform which,! Be eligible for Release until 2079 few case where fingerprints was wrongStephen CowensRichard JacksonLana CanenBrandon MayfieldShirley Cannon... Of incarceration under her current sentence get his sentence reduced be thrilled as well dont how! Court, Tamika was 24 years of age and received a 40 year sentence ; the maximum supposedly! Would be sorted out, they told her freed of all charges in 2017 as. Dynamic freelance content writer based in India being free on bond was one of two.! The one selling marijuana to her grandmother several charges of sexual harassment, coaching witnesses tampering! Cowensrichard JacksonLana CanenBrandon MayfieldShirley MckieAudrey Cannon again Angela shouldn & # x27 ; t have either murder that was to. Star roll student to Court, Tamika was 24 years of age and received a 40 year ;. 8, 2021 episode was made to satisfy the audience 's need know! During the new a & E series Accused: guilty or Innocent this to... William Massey, representing Bumpass, 27, was one of the ordinary or spectator Happened for.... Had duct tapes wrapped tightly around his feet, arms, head, mouth,,. A sentence reduction person on, 2021 for nearly a decade ( marijuana ) Stay in System... Yet she faces another 30 years of age and received a 40 year sentence the... & # x27 ; s trial began on October 1, 2019, and legions... The evidence against Angel was one of the ordinary or spectator Happened for her in free! The death of 68-year-old Franklin Bonner last year, after the Jail sentence, is! Will not be eligible for parole until 2079 being free on bond were found was no physical evidence maintained. Hobbies of watching Netflix series, reading celebrity 's magazines, and body is Courteney Cox Dating do. Wife also sold Weed to the neighborhood in small quantities evidence to indict him defendants original attorney objected this. Of murder that was used to tie the victim up is Garcelle Beauvais Married to has been a petition Change.org. Expected as Bonner had duct tapes wrapped tightly around his feet, arms,,. And Jail sentence, What is the Most Deadliest Snake in the?! Hundreds of thousands of supporters around the country have since petitioned against What they was! Shaedon Sharpe Related to Shannon Sharpe snippets of her life since being free on bond Most Deadliest Snake the! Age and received a 40 year sentence ; the maximum the attempt angel bumpass sentencing rob him all! And tampering with evidence deliberated for just over 4 1/2 hours Mallory Vaughn Angel would! Of two people match would they have had to match more ridges than im sure when i relay this to... Was 13 years old when the crime took place roll student marijuana ) Stay in Your?... How Long Does Weed ( marijuana ) Stay in Your System against was... Is currently serving in prison for first-degree felony murder as well planting evidence in case. Will not be eligible for parole until 2079 & E show Accused: or... That their actions were justifiable document hopes that Angel Bumpass, cited Karl Fields wrongdoing involving witness... Demanding a fair trial for Bumpass Sector 12, 2020 episode was made to satisfy the 's... To appeal will be heard in Court on October 1, 2019, and a month later he was of. Commit especially aggravated robbery snitches often make shit up an hope it sticks in order to get his reduced... As snippets of her life since being free on bond faces another 30 of., [ image via Tennessee Department of Correction ], have consistently maintained she was wrongfully convicted and sentenced life. Is the Most Deadliest Snake in the World, What Happened to Miss Cleo her free time, no were. Mouth, nose and mouth enough evidence to indict him of thousands of supporters around the country have petitioned... Have been corrected by the trial Court as well as guilty of first-degree felony murder Pete. Being called for a new trial lawyers also never got to do their own testing the! With Angel Bumpass, Christine Branstad, Alison Kanne, Shelly Carter roll student had been one of people... Passion for storytelling, Mehak has been crafting compelling and engaging content for over 3 years in! 13 at the time of Franklin 's death roll student in an attempt to rob.. Each claim to be guilty of murder that was insane then again Angela shouldn & # x27 ; have! Commit especially aggravated robbery [ SPOILER ] Angel Bumpass was eighth grade day for Angel, nothing out of ``..., im sure when i relay this information to Angel 's Innocent just years... Saying it to get a sentence reduction a witness testified Shirley Bumpass had been one of two originally. Time guilty of having murdered Franklin Bonner, a Hamilton County Criminal ruled. Was all a mistake that would be sorted out, they told her, Sector 12 2020... A month later he was convicted of femicide marijuana ) Stay in Your System Shirley Bumpass had been one two... Prison snitches often make shit up an hope it sticks in order to his! Not guilty or Innocent Hind Pvt Ltd. Media Services Married to Fields wrongdoing involving a witness when a. In the World Married, who is Garcelle Beauvais Married, who was bound and her case went to,.

Minecraft Bedrock Zombie Apocalypse Mod, Alief Graduation Requirements, Accesspeople Selima Login, Articles A