In some cases, papers that are rejected in one Nature Portfolio journal might be the right fit for another Nature Portfolio journal. Improve the chances of your manuscripts acceptance by learning how to prepare a manuscript for journal submission and handle the peer review process. Cactus Communications. (LogOut/ The editor is checking for any problems with formatting and all criteria have been met. Or it just means that an editor is evaluating it? As you already seem to know, the Awaiting Decision status means that the AE has made a decision on the manuscript and referred this decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EIC) for the final decision. Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, What happens if a reviewer withdraws himself from peer review process? EB: Editors in different journals typically communicate with each other if they think a paper might be suited for a different journal (unless authors have explicitly asked for such communications not to happen). WebNature Communications is a peer-reviewed, open access, scientific journal published by Nature Research since 2010. What is the meaning of decision in process status? EB: Like Nature Physics, Communication Physics is primarily a physics journal. PW: A transfer system is in place to ensure that an author can find the best place for their paper in the Nature Portfolio. WebNature Neuroscience manuscript stage. NOV: Nature Communicationss editorial criteria include a significant advance and the potential of a paper to influence thinking in its specific field, or a paper that introduces a new idea or technology or technologically viable solution to real-life problems. The panel discussion was moderated by yours truly. "Editorial assessment of reviews" can mean that all reviewer send back their reviews and "Manuscript under editorial consideration" could mean that the editor hit the button "look at review". I think both my fingers and my stomach will be crossed until I find out the real answer! Does this mean that they have already sent it out to the reviewers? LS: I dont care who you are, or where youre from. Are there conventions to indicate a new item in a list? quality, format, scientific novelty, language etc). Got lab stories? So, the present status may mean that the EiC now needs to make a decision based on the peer review comments or on the revised manuscript. Once the corresponding author approves these, your article is compiled into an issue of the journal and is published in its final form. Also, if it had to be negative outcome, it wouldnt take so //--> I think the online submission system is very similar to other journals, so I thought someone might help me to understad this. Thanks for the response! It probably means nothing. WebThe editor is reading your manuscript and figuring out whether or not she wants to send it for peer review. Does it mean that the original reviewers are now not accessible anymore? The next status "Under review" in my opinion refers to the admin check which is conducted by editorial assistants to ensure that the journal's basic requirements with Is presently being given full consideration for publication? Unless it is just rejected by an editor.So, OP, it is good. There are weekly meetings on which the editorial board (the paid by the journal) meet and check which manuscript to send to reviewers and select those reviewers.In my experience they are at the end of the week, because we usually get editorial decision friday or monday. Once a paper is submitted to a journal, it is assigned to a handling editor who conducts an initial screening of the paper to see if it meets the basic requirements of the journal. //--> Original research ranges from new concepts in human biology and disease pathogenesis to robust preclinical bases for new therapeutic modalities and drug development to all phases of clinical work, as well as innovative technologies Sorry we couldn't be helpful. //--> Whether or not reviewers have accepted the invitation is usually confidential information available only to journal staff. The manuscript was under review when it was showing 'all reviewers assigned' and when the status changed to 'under consideration' it means that reviews are back with her and she is discussing it with her collegues. The editors in attendance were Leslie Sage (LS, Nature), May Chiao and Paul Woods (MC and PW, Nature Astronomy), Iulia Georgescu (IG, Nature Reviews Physics), Stefanie Reichert (SR, Nature Physics), Nilda Oklay-Vincent (NOV, Nature Communications) and Elena Belsole (EB, Communications Physics). We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses. EB: Typical assessment times from editors are shorter than 7 days and as such you are encouraged to submit your full paper directly to the journal and you will receive a timely response. About. Decision in Process on the Elsevier Editorial System (EES) means that the editor has logged a decision in the system but is awaiting confirmation from the Editor-in-Chief (EiC). gebirgsziege on Wed Jun 27 07:39:58 2012 said: 1999-2013 Protocol Online, All rights reserved.